Mapping lower-limbs muscle vulnerability in patients with ALS: The role of upper and lower motor neurons

Background: Several studies have reported disproportionate wasting of the flexor muscles of the lower limbs (LL) compared to the extensors in patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). However, these studies have involved small sample sizes (n 〈100), and their findings have been inconsistent. Thus, it remains uncertain whether a distinct pattern of LL muscle weakness is specific to ALS. Aims: To investigate the muscle weakness pattern in the LL at the knee, ankle, and toes in a large cohort of ALS patients and evaluate the relationship between the pattern of muscle strength and the extent of upper (UMN) and lower (LMN) motoneuron impairment. Material and methods: The strength of flexor and extensor muscle was evaluated in 1250 legs of newly diagnosed ALS patients at the knee, ankle, and foot toes. UMN and LMN burden were assessed using validated scores. Within-subjects ANOVA considering the type of muscle (flexor/extensor) and anatomical sites (knee/ankle/toes) and mixed-factorial ANOVA were conducted to explore the impact of UMN and LMN impairments on the muscle weakness pattern. Results: Muscle strength showed a significant decline from proximal to distal regions. Indeed both flexor and extensor muscles at the knee outperformed those at the ankle and toes. Within each site, extensor muscles exhibited less strength than flexor, except at the knee. Patients with heightened UMN impairment showed a more marked difference between flexors and extensors within each site, with extensor muscles being more compromised at the ankle and toes. Higher LMN impairment corresponded to a more pronounced weakness in flexor muscles at the ankle and toes compared to those at the knee. Conclusions: The extensor muscle at the knee and the flexors at the foot and toes displayed relative resistance to ALS disease. UMN impairment amplified the differences between flexor and extensor muscles within each site, while LMN impairment demonstrated a clear distal-to-proximal vulnerability.